Hot Coffee: the sex minigame Rockstar left on the San Andreas disc, and how it nearly sank the game
Rockstar locked it away instead of deleting it. A modder found it, the game got re-rated Adults Only, shops pulled it, and it ended in a federal settlement. Here's the whole story.
By Wes Calloway
In 2004 Rockstar built a sex minigame for Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas, decided not to use it, and switched it off. It didn't delete it. The code stayed on the disc, and a year later that decision cost the company tens of millions of dollars and a fight with the US government.
How it got found
On 9 June 2005 a Dutch modder called Patrick Wildenborg released a patch for the PC version that switched the minigame back on. He called it Hot Coffee, after the line CJ's girlfriends use to invite him in. It was downloaded over a million times in four weeks.
Rockstar's first response, on 14 July, was that the content was "the work of a determined group of hackers." That line didn't last. People quickly showed the scenes were already in the game files on every copy, including the console versions. The mod didn't add anything. It just unlocked what Rockstar had shipped.
Re-rated, pulled, recalled
On 20 July 2005 the US ratings board, the ESRB, changed San Andreas from M to AO, Adults Only. That rating's basically a death sentence in America, since the big retailers won't stock AO games. Many of them pulled San Andreas off the shelves that week.
Rockstar put out a patch that disabled Hot Coffee, re-labelled or recalled existing stock, and released a new M-rated version without it. Take-Two later said the returns tied to the re-rating cost it $24.5 million.
Politics, lawsuits and the FTC
Hot Coffee turned into a national story. Senator Hillary Clinton asked the Federal Trade Commission to look into the game. A class action followed, filed by an 85-year-old woman in New York, which settled in 2008 for up to $35 per buyer. Fewer than 3,000 people bothered to claim.
The FTC settled with Take-Two and Rockstar in June 2006. It said they'd advertised an M rating without disclosing content that didn't fit it. There was no fine, but the order means up to $11,000 per violation if they ever do it again, and it made them set up a system to review everything on a disc when they apply for a rating.
Why it still matters for GTA 6
The review system is the real legacy. Since Hot Coffee, Rockstar's been far more careful about what ships on a disc and what ratings boards see. GTA 6 is rated M in the US and PEGI 18, and you can bet every scrap of content on it was checked against that rating. Cut content still exists in every big game. It just doesn't get left lying around the way it did in 2004.
Are you playing GTA 6 on day one?
Votes are anonymous. One per browser.
Sources
Keep reading
What 9/11 changed in GTA III: the cop cars, a cut mission, and a cover made in one evening
Rockstar delayed GTA III by three weeks after the attacks and said the game ended up "about 1% different". Here's what that 1% was.
2 min read
GTA nearly got cancelled, and a police bug saved it
It started in 1995 as a game called Race'n'Chase. It crashed constantly, the driving was bad, the publisher wanted out. Then the cops started ramming people.
2 min read
The first GTA's moral panic was a PR job, and the man behind it was Max Clifford
In 1997 the team behind Grand Theft Auto hired Britain's most notorious publicist. The tabloid outrage that followed was the plan.
2 min read